How do you write a regret mail to a candidate?
Write a regret mail to each candidate once you've decided they aren't going forward, and send it that day. Name the role, thank them, state the decision in one sentence, and stop. After an interview, add two or three sentences of feedback from your notes on their answers.
- Make the decision first, and write the regret mail after.
- Pick the mail: after the application, or after the interview.
- Put the role in the subject line.
- Use the candidate's name, and the client's, or "a confidential client".
- Thank them for applying, or for their time in the interview.
- Say in one sentence that you won't take the application forward.
- Keep the reason in your own records, not in the email.
- After an interview, add one strength and one or two gaps.
- Read it once, and cut anything that argues the decision.
- Send it the day you decide.
Where you record each rejection reason, coded to the stage that would have caught it, is set out in the candidate screening process guide.
What goes in a regret mail?
A regret mail has five parts: a subject line naming the role, a greeting by name, a line of thanks, the decision in one sentence, and a sign-off. After an interview it can carry a sixth, two or three sentences of feedback. Everything else stays in your notes.
Subject line
Name the role, so the candidate knows which application it is before opening it: "Your application: [Role]", or after an interview, "An update on your application: [Role]". A candidate may have several applications open with you, and the role tells them which one this is.
Greeting
Use their name. Name the client too, or say "a confidential client" if the client hasn't agreed to be named.
Thanks
Thank them for applying, or for the time they spent in the interview. One line is enough.
The decision
One plain sentence: "We won't be taking your application forward for this role." Add that you'll keep their details for a closer fit only if you do keep them. The download marks that line "[Only if you keep their details:]" in all three mails.
Feedback, after an interview
One strength, then one or two gaps, in the role's terms and from what the candidate said. Leave out scores, rankings and other candidates, what the client said, anything about how the interview was monitored, and personal traits such as age, gender, background, accent, appearance or health. Don't give the reason for the decision, and don't promise a future role.
Who should get feedback, what each exclusion is for and when to send it are in how to give candidate feedback after rejection.
Sign-off
Your name and the agency. If replies to the address won't be read, say so, so the candidate isn't left waiting for an answer.
What does a rejection email after an interview look like, with feedback?
A rejection email after an interview, with feedback, is the after-interview mail plus one paragraph: a strength, then the gaps. This one was rendered by Recagn on 18 Nov 2026 from a worked example, for an invented candidate for an inside sales role in Pune. Its feedback is the AI's draft, unedited.
Read the tags: only the feedback paragraph is the AI's draft, written from the reasoning above it; the rest is Recagn's fixed template.
Who isn't going forward
- The rule
- Lowest weighted score: sum of weight times score over the scored criteria, divided by the sum of those weights. A tie goes to the earlier candidate id. A Candidate whose bucket is qualified is never rejected.the worked example's rule, standing in for you
- Debashish Mahapatra
- 1.15 out of 5 · Recagn recommends Disqualified · rejected by the rulereport
- Nisha Pillai
- 4.00 out of 5 · Recagn recommends Qualifiedreport
What the draft is written from
- B2C Sales & Conversion
- The candidate has no sales ownership or conversion responsibility. The role-play pitch is a generic one-line product assertion with no discovery, tailoring, or close. They explicitly confirm no sales targets and no closing experience, describing only data-entry and support roles. This maps directly to anchor 1.Recagn's reasoning, per criterion
- Counselling & Needs Discovery
- The pitch is a one-size-fits-all script with no attempt to understand the prospect's role, goals, or constraints. The discovery answer does not list a single discovery question; it only describes jotting names to call back later. No needs discovery whatsoever, matching anchor 1.Recagn's reasoning, per criterion
- Objection Handling & Persuasion
- Faced with a price/competitor objection, the candidate offers only a flat assertion that the course is better, with no technique to isolate the concern, reframe value, or create urgency. They explicitly admit no experience. This is the give-up/defensive level of anchor 1.Recagn's reasoning, per criterion
- Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Management
- No follow-up cadence, no lead prioritisation, and no CRM experience. Relying on calling back 'when I remember' is reactive and system-less, with no method to prevent leads slipping through. This matches anchor 1.Recagn's reasoning, per criterion
- Communication & Confidence
- Language is understandable and grammatically correct, but the delivery lacks confidence, structure, and persuasive content. The written follow-up task was not even attempted correctly — instead of a re-engagement message, the candidate answered about location and intent. This lack of structure and task relevance keeps it at anchor 2.Recagn's reasoning, per criterion
The email
- Subject
- An update on your application: Inside sales / admissions counsellorRecagn's fixed template
- Heading
- YOUR APPLICATIONRecagn's fixed template
- Greeting
- Hi Debashish Mahapatra,Recagn's fixed template
- Decision
- Thank you for taking the time to interview for Inside sales / admissions counsellor (An EdTech company in Pune). We won't be taking your application forward for this role. We'll keep your details in case something closer fits.Recagn's fixed template
- Feedback
- Some feedback from your interview: Your language came across as clear and easy to understand, which is a solid foundation for a client-facing role. That said, the interview highlighted two areas that were not yet at the level needed for this position: in the sales and objection-handling scenarios, your answers focused on general assertions rather than exploring a prospect's specific needs or addressing their concerns with tailored reasoning, and your approach to following up with leads was more reactive than structured, without a consistent method to track and prioritise contacts. These are core requirements of the role, so we are not moving forward at this time.AI draft, unedited
- Sign-off
- Best wishes, Orchard Talent Partnersinvented agency
- Footer
- Sent by Orchard Talent Partners via Recagn. Replies to this address aren't read. Opt out https://recagn.app/optout/example of emails from every recruiter on Recagn.example link
Two invented candidates answered the interview for the role. Recagn scored both against the role's scorecard, which Recagn calls a rubric: Nisha Pillai 4.00 out of 5, and Debashish Mahapatra 1.15. The worked example's written rule then rejected the lower score, as you would, and it never rejects a candidate Recagn recommends as Qualified. Recagn recommended Disqualified for Debashish; the rejection was the rule's, standing in for you.
The feedback is drafted only from Recagn's reasoning on each criterion, the five notes in the middle of the figure. The draft sees no score, no ranking, no other candidate and nothing about how the interview was monitored. It is asked for one strength, then one or two gaps.
It gets most of that right. The strength, that his language was "clear and easy to understand", matches the reasoning on Communication & Confidence. The two gaps, general assertions instead of a prospect's needs and follow-up that was reactive, not structured, are the reasoning on the sales, discovery, objection and follow-up criteria, without a number.
Read before sending, one sentence would go. "These are core requirements of the role, so we are not moving forward at this time" gives the reason, which the draft is told not to do, and repeats the decision the email has already stated. Here it is left in, because this draft was never reviewed or sent.
Recagn is our product. When you set a candidate to Rejected after the interview, Recagn offers the rejection email for review: the fixed text, a box for your own message, and feedback you write or ask the AI to draft. The draft is tagged as an AI draft until you edit or confirm it, and you get three drafts per candidate for each role. Nothing goes until you press Send. The email then waits 10 minutes, during which you can cancel it, and goes only if the candidate can still be emailed. Candidates you've rejected but not yet emailed sit on a Not yet told list, and you can review and send to up to 200 of them at once, with the same 10-minute wait.
Drafting the feedback comes off your plate. Who is rejected, and what they're told, stays yours. Recagn recommends. Only you can reject a candidate.
Where the decision sits in the flow is in how Recagn works.
Questions people ask
Is this regret mail template free?
Yes. The Word file with all three regret mails is free to download, with no email or sign-up asked, and you can change it however you like. Sending rejection emails from Recagn uses no credit.
Should AI write the feedback in a rejection email?
Only as a draft you read first. Recagn drafts two or three sentences from its reasoning on each criterion, never from scores, rankings or how the interview was monitored. The draft is marked as AI until you edit or confirm it, and nothing is sent until you press Send; it then waits 10 minutes, during which you can cancel it.
How is this different from Keka's or Hyring's rejection email templates?
It adds feedback, with what to put in and what to leave out, and shows one email Recagn rendered for an invented candidate, with its feedback as the AI drafted it. Keka's templates cover ten situations; none puts interview feedback in the email, and one invites the candidate to ask for it. Hyring's generator fills a letter from the candidate's name, the role and the company, in a formal, modern or friendly tone. We read both on 18 Nov 2026.
Should a regret mail to a candidate say why they were rejected?
No. State the decision once and keep the reason in your records. After an interview, feedback on what the answers showed is more use to the candidate than a reason they can't act on, and it doesn't invite an argument about the decision.