Recagn
Sign in

Template · Scoring

Interview evaluation form: scores, quotes and a decision per candidate

Fill in one copy for each candidate straight after the interview, before you talk about them with anyone.

interview-evaluation-form.docxWord document · 11 KB · free, no sign-up

How do you fill in an interview evaluation form?

Fill in one interview evaluation form for each candidate, straight after the interview and before you discuss them with anyone. Score against the role's interview scorecard, which stays the same for every candidate. The recommendation follows from the form; the decision is yours.

  1. Make one copy for each candidate and each interviewer.
  2. Copy the gates, criteria, weights and cut-offs from the role's scorecard.
  3. Note the date of the scorecard copy you score against.
  4. Fill it in straight after the interview, before any discussion.
  5. Mark each gate met or not met, with the answer that shows it.
  6. If the answers don't show a gate, mark it not met.
  7. Score one criterion at a time, against its anchors.
  8. Quote the answer each score rests on.
  9. Work out the weighted total to two decimals.
  10. Write your decision apart from the recommendation, and why they differ.

The gates, weights, anchors and cut-offs come from the interview scorecard template, written once for the role.

What goes on an interview feedback form?

An interview feedback form, or evaluation form, has six parts: the interview, the hard gates, the scored criteria, the total, the recommendation and your decision. It holds one candidate's answers and scores; the gates, weights, anchors and cut-offs come from the role's scorecard.

The interview

The candidate's name, or initials if the form may be shared; the client and role as the scorecard names them; the interview date; and the interviewer. "Scorecard used" is the date of the scorecard copy you scored against. If the scorecard changes mid-role, candidates scored on the earlier copy keep it, so you compare like with like.

Hard gates

Copy each gate from the scorecard. A gate is met or not met, never scored, and beside it goes the answer that shows it. If the answers don't show it, mark it not met.

Scored criteria

The criterion and its weight out of 100 come from the scorecard. You add a score from 1 to 5 against its anchors, and the quote or note the score rests on. Score one criterion at a time, using only the answers to its questions, so one strong answer doesn't lift every score.

Total

Multiply each score by its weight, add them up, and divide by the total weight. Write the result to two decimals, beside the two cut-offs as the scorecard sets them.

Recommendation

Move on, maybe or no, read from the gates and the total. Any gate not met means no, whatever the score. "Filled in" records the date and time, which should come before any discussion of the candidate: a form filled in after the panel has talked records the group's view, not yours.

Decision

Your decision goes in a field of its own. If it differs from the recommendation, say why. Kept apart, the two show later how often you overrode the score, which tells you whether the weights or cut-offs need changing.

How to compare two interviewers' forms on the same candidate is in the interview scorecard guide.

What does a filled-in interview evaluation form look like?

A filled-in interview evaluation form gives each gate the answer that settles it, each criterion a score and a quote, then the total and a recommendation beside an empty decision. This one is filled in from a worked example: invented candidate N, scored by Recagn on 8 Nov 2026 against the scorecard drafted for the same role.

The interview evaluation form, filled in for one candidate from a worked example

Read the "yours" tags: each marks a value you fill in after the interview.

interview-evaluation-form.docxExample filled in

The interview

Candidate
N, an invented candidate: initials onlyreport
Client and role
An EdTech company in Pune · Inside sales / admissions counsellorreport
Interview date
8 Nov 2026, the worked example's runrun
Interviewer
Recagn scored this copy. A second interviewer fills in a form of their own.run
Scorecard used
The rubric Recagn drafted on 8 Nov 2026, locked uneditedrun

Hard gates

Hard gateMet or not metThe answer that shows it
Pune on-site availabilityyoursQ7: 'Yes. I live in Pune'
1-3 years B2C / inside sales experienceyoursQ3: 'I’ve been an admissions counsellor for two and a half years.'
Clear spoken communicationyoursQ1, a voice answer: transcript on the report

Scored criteria

CriterionWeight (of 100)Score (1 to 5)Quote or note the score rests on
B2C Sales & Conversion Skill254'Over the last year I averaged fourteen enrolments a month against a target of eleven.'answer · Q3
Counselling, Persuasion & Objection Handling254'I never cut the price first.'answer · Q2
Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Management205'Every lead gets a next step logged the same day.'answer · Q4
Target-Driven Ownership & Motivation155'September I closed fifteen.'answer · Q6
CRM & Sales Reporting Fluency155'On Fridays I pull the stage report to see where leads stall'answer · Q5

Total

Weighted score
4.50worked out
Cut-offs used
3.6 to move on · 2.8 for maybedraft rubric

Recommendation

Recommendation
Recagn recommends Qualified: 4.50, at or above the 3.6 cut-offreport; worked out
Filled in
Scored by Recagn on 8 Nov 2026run

Decision

Your decision
Not made: a worked example has no decision.yours
Why it differs
yours
Worked example · Inside sales / admissions counsellor, An EdTech company in Pune · Adapted from a real public job posting; company details removed · Invented candidate N, scored by Recagn on 8 Nov 2026 against the rubric it drafted, locked unedited

Tags mark where a value came from, and only some cells carry one. The filled-in fields name the worked example's report or run, Recagn's draft, or "worked out". Each quote is tagged with the question it answers. The cells left for you to fill in after the interview read "yours". The gate names, the gate answers, the criteria, the weights and the scores carry no tag; where they come from is below.

N is scored against the same scorecard shown filled in on the interview scorecard template page: three gates, five weighted criteria, and cut-offs of 3.6 and 2.8.

The answer column for the gates quotes N. On question 7: "Yes. I live in Pune". On question 3: "I’ve been an admissions counsellor for two and a half years." Question 1 is answered by voice only, so the form points to its transcript on the report. The "Met or not met" column is left for you. The client report Recagn shares gives no verdict for each gate; it lists only a gate Recagn couldn't settle, and for N there is none. Recagn recommends Qualified only when every gate is met, so its recommendation already says it found all three met.

N scored 4 on the two criteria weighted 25 (sales and conversion; counselling and objection handling) and 5 on the three weighted 20, 15 and 15 (follow-up and pipeline; target-driven ownership; CRM and reporting). The scores are Recagn's, from the worked example's report. The quotes are ours: we took each one from N's answer to that criterion's question and checked it against the answer. Each is a line a score could rest on, not text Recagn wrote.

The total works out as (4 × 25 + 4 × 25 + 5 × 20 + 5 × 15 + 5 × 15) ÷ 100 = 4.50. That is at or above the 3.6 cut-off, so Recagn recommends Qualified, the form's "move on".

"Your decision" reads "Not made", because a worked example has no decision, and "Why it differs" is blank. On a real form you write both after reading the recommendation, never in its place. The interviewer line says Recagn scored N's answers on this copy, and that a second interviewer fills in a form of their own.

Recagn is our product. For every candidate who finishes the interview, Recagn fills in the equivalent of this form against the scorecard, which Recagn calls a rubric. It checks each hard gate first and marks it not met when the answers don't show it. It scores each criterion from 1 to 5 against its anchors, using only the answers to that criterion's questions, and writes a reason beside each score. It works out the weighted total and recommends Qualified, Maybe or Disqualified. You approve the recommendation or override it with a note, and Recagn keeps its recommendation beside yours. Recagn recommends. Only you can reject a candidate.

Scoring every answer against the rubric comes off your plate. Whether a candidate moves on stays yours.

How each score becomes a recommendation is set out in how AI interview scoring works.

Questions people ask

Is this interview evaluation form free?

Yes. The Word file is free to download, with no email or sign-up asked, and you can change it however you like.

If Recagn scores the interview, is the decision really the AI's?

No. Recagn scores each answer against the scorecard, which Recagn calls a rubric, and recommends Qualified, Maybe or Disqualified. You approve that recommendation or override it with a note, and Recagn keeps both. Only you can reject a candidate, which is why the form keeps your decision in a field of its own.

How is this different from AIHR's or 100Hires' interview evaluation forms?

This one adds hard gates marked met or not, with the answer that shows each, a weight for every criterion, a weighted total read against cut-offs set before the interview, and your decision in a field apart from the recommendation. 100Hires' sample form rates six competencies from 1 to 5, with a notes and examples column beside each rating, and ends with a hire or no-hire recommendation. AIHR's template runs from personal information and skills to impressions, ranking and next steps. We read both on 17 Nov 2026.

Should every interviewer fill in their own evaluation form?

Yes. Everyone who interviews the candidate fills in a separate copy against the same scorecard, without seeing anyone else's. Put the forms side by side only once all of them are in. A wide gap on one criterion usually means its anchor needs clearer wording.

Bring a role you're screening for to the demo.