How do you use an interview scorecard template?
Fill in one interview scorecard per role from the client brief, before any candidate is invited, and get the client to agree it. Every candidate is then scored against that same copy. You decide what goes on it; the client signs it off.
- Start from the client brief the client signed off.
- Sort each need into a hard gate or a scored criterion.
- Keep the gates few; ask which ones the client would trade.
- Write each criterion as work a candidate can describe.
- Give each criterion a weight; make the weights add up to 100.
- Write anchors 1, 3 and 5 first, then 2 and 4.
- Link at least one question to every gate and criterion.
- Set both cut-offs before the first interview.
- Send it to the client to agree, and date it.
- Score each candidate on a separate form, against this copy.
How to sort gates from criteria and write anchors is set out in the interview scorecard guide.
What goes on a scorecard template?
A scorecard template has seven parts: the role, the hard gates, the scored criteria with their weights, the anchors, the interview questions, the cut-offs and the client's sign-off. It holds no candidate's scores; those go on a separate form for each candidate.
The role
The client and the role, written as they are on the signed-off client brief. The date the brief was signed off ties this scorecard to what the client agreed. "Prepared by" says who wrote it, and when.
Hard gates
A gate is pass or fail, never scored. "Passes when" says what an answer must show, and "Question that settles it" names the question that checks it, because a gate with no question can only be guessed. If the answers don't show it, mark it not met. Take gates only from the brief's must-haves, and keep the list short: each gate removes people outright.
Scored criteria
Each row holds the criterion's name, what it covers, its weight out of 100 and the questions that test it. Three to six criteria cover most roles. The weighted score is each 1 to 5 score times its weight, added up and divided by the total weight, so it stays between 1 and 5.
Anchors for one criterion
Copy this section once for each criterion. Each anchor says what an answer at that score shows: a number, an example, a step the candidate describes. Write 1, 3 and 5 first (no evidence, enough evidence, and the strongest answer you expect to hear), then 2 and 4 between them.
Interview questions
One row per question, with the gate or criteria it tests. A question that tests nothing on the scorecard should be cut, unless it shows the scorecard is missing a criterion.
Cut-offs
Two numbers on the 1 to 5 weighted score: the score to move on from, and the score for maybe. Below maybe, or with any hard gate failed, the candidate is not recommended, whatever the total. Set both before the first interview. Changing one after you've seen the candidates means choosing the candidate first and the rule second.
Sign-off
Who agreed the scorecard for the client, on what date, and how: an email reply or a signature. Record any change made after interviews start, with its date, because candidates already interviewed were scored on the earlier copy. Each candidate's scores go on a separate evaluation form, one for each interview.
That form, with each field explained and one candidate's copy filled in, is the interview evaluation form template.
What does a filled-in interview scorecard look like?
A filled-in interview scorecard gives each gate its pass condition and every criterion a weight, five anchors and a linked question, with the cut-offs fixed in advance. This one is filled in from a worked example: the scorecard Recagn drafted on 8 Nov 2026 for an inside sales posting adapted from a real one, locked unedited.
Read the "yours" tags: each marks a value you fill in with your client.
The role
- Client and role
- An EdTech company in Pune · Inside sales / admissions counsellorreport
- Brief signed off
- Not signed: a worked example has no client.yours
- Prepared by
- Drafted by Recagn on 8 Nov 2026 from the posting, locked uneditedrun
Hard gates
| Hard gate | Passes when | Question that settles it |
|---|---|---|
| Pune on-site availabilitydraft rubric | Candidate must be able to work full-time on-site in Pune, Monday to Saturday. No remote or field-sales arrangement. | Q7 |
| 1-3 years B2C / inside sales experiencedraft rubric | Candidate must have 1-3 years of relevant experience in B2C sales, inside sales, EdTech/education sales, admissions, or academic/career counselling. | Q3 |
| Clear spoken communicationdraft rubric | Candidate must be able to communicate clearly and confidently over phone/video with students and working professionals. | Q1, by voice |
Scored criteria
| Criterion | What it covers | Weight (of 100) | Questions that test it |
|---|---|---|---|
| B2C Sales & Conversion Skilldraft rubric | Ability to convert qualified inbound leads into paid enrolments, present programmes persuasively, and consistently hit monthly/quarterly targets. | 25 | Q1, Q2, Q3, Q6 |
| Counselling, Persuasion & Objection Handlingdraft rubric | Ability to understand a prospect's goals, recommend the right programme, build trust, and handle objections on price, timing, competitors and decision-makers without damaging experience. | 25 | Q1, Q2 |
| Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Managementdraft rubric | Self-driven, structured follow-up on every prospect, prioritising high-intent leads, and keeping the CRM accurate so no qualified lead is lost. | 20 | Q4, Q5 |
| Target-Driven Ownership & Motivationdraft rubric | Motivated by incentives and monthly targets; owns their numbers and thrives in a high-volume lead environment. | 15 | Q3, Q6, Q7 |
| CRM & Sales Reporting Fluencydraft rubric | Working knowledge of CRM systems and sales reporting to manage pipeline and track performance. | 15 | Q5 |
| yours | yours | yours | yours |
Anchors for one criterion
- Criterion
- Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Managementdraft rubric
- Score 1
- Follows up only when reminded; no system; lets leads go cold.draft rubric
- Score 2
- Inconsistent follow-up; tracks leads loosely in notes or memory.draft rubric
- Score 3
- Keeps a regular follow-up cadence and updates CRM reliably.draft rubric
- Score 4
- Disciplined, prioritised follow-up with a clear cadence; prevents leakage and tracks own numbers.draft rubric
- Score 5
- Highly systematic: segments by intent, times follow-ups strategically, maintains pristine CRM and self-monitors against daily/weekly/monthly targets.draft rubric
Interview questions
| Question | Gate or criteria it tests |
|---|---|
| Q1 Imagine a working professional calls in, unsure whether an upskilling programme is worth the fees. In your own words, pitch a programme to them and convince them it is right for their career. Please answer by voice as if you were on the call.draft rubric | Gate: Clear spoken communication · B2C Sales & Conversion Skill · Counselling, Persuasion & Objection Handling |
| Q2 A prospect says: 'Your programme is too expensive, a competitor offers something similar for less.' Walk us through exactly how you would handle this objection and move toward a close.draft rubric | Counselling, Persuasion & Objection Handling · B2C Sales & Conversion Skill |
| Q3 Describe your most recent sales or counselling role: how many leads did you work, what was your conversion rate, and how did you perform against targets? Give concrete numbers.draft rubric | Gate: 1-3 years B2C / inside sales experience · B2C Sales & Conversion Skill · Target-Driven Ownership & Motivation |
| Q4 How do you organise your follow-ups so no qualified lead slips through, especially when you have many leads at once? Describe your system or cadence.draft rubric | Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Management |
| Q5 Which CRM or lead-management tools have you used, and how do you use pipeline stages and sales reports in your day-to-day work?draft rubric | CRM & Sales Reporting Fluency · Follow-up Discipline & Pipeline Management |
| Q6 This role is target-driven with performance incentives. Tell us about a month you fell short of target, what happened, and what you did about it.draft rubric | Target-Driven Ownership & Motivation · B2C Sales & Conversion Skill |
| Q7 This is an on-site role in Pune, working Monday to Saturday with no remote or field sales. Can you confirm you are available for this, and are you currently based in or willing to relocate to Pune?draft rubric | Gate: Pune on-site availability · Target-Driven Ownership & Motivation |
| yours | yours |
Cut-offs
- Move on from
- 3.6: Recagn recommends Qualifieddraft rubric
- Maybe from
- 2.8: Recagn recommends Maybedraft rubric
- Not recommended
- Below 2.8, or any hard gate failed: Recagn recommends Disqualifieddraft rubric
Sign-off
- Agreed with the client
- Yours: a worked example has no client to agree it.yours
- Changes after interviews start
- None. Four invented candidates were scored on this copy.run
Each value is tagged with where it came from: Recagn's draft, the worked example's report or run, or "yours", for a value you fill in with your client.
There are three hard gates, and one question settles each. Question 7 checks on-site work in Pune, question 3 checks one to three years of B2C or inside sales, and question 1 checks clear spoken communication. Candidates answer question 1 by voice only.
The five criteria weigh 25, 25, 20, 15 and 15 out of 100. Each is tested by between one and four of the seven questions.
The anchors are shown in full for one criterion, follow-up discipline and pipeline management, weighted 20. It is the criterion the interview scorecard guide scores at four levels, on four candidates' answers to question 4. The other four criteria's anchors are in the same scorecard's Word file on that guide.
The cut-offs are 3.6 and 2.8. At 3.6 or above, Recagn recommends Qualified; from 2.8, Maybe; below 2.8, or with any gate failed, Disqualified.
"Brief signed off" and "Agreed with the client" read "yours", because a worked example has no client to sign it. There is no notice-period or pay gate either. The posting gives no notice period, and its pay line names no figure, so adding either gate is your edit.
The scorecards Recagn drafted for six worked examples, this one included, download as Word files in the interview scorecard guide.
Recagn is our product. Recagn drafts the scorecard, which Recagn calls a rubric, from the client's job description and any notes you add: hard gates, weighted criteria with an anchor for each of the five points, two cut-offs, and interview questions linked to the criterion or gate each one tests. You edit it and lock it before anyone is invited, and every candidate is scored against that locked version. Locking an edited rubric makes a new version. Recagn recommends Qualified, Maybe or Disqualified. Only you can reject a candidate.
Drafting the rubric from the job description comes off your plate. What the role needs, the questions and the hard gates stay yours.
How each score becomes a recommendation is set out in how AI interview scoring works.
Questions people ask
Is this interview scorecard template free?
Yes. The Word file is free to download, with no email or sign-up asked, and you can change it however you like.
Can a scorecard drafted by AI miss something the client needs?
Yes. Recagn drafts from the job description and any notes you add, so a need neither of them states is left out. None of the six postings in the interview scorecard guide mentions a notice period, and none of their scorecards has a notice-period gate. You edit the draft and lock it before anyone is invited.
How is this different from Metaview's or Manatal's scorecard templates?
This one puts hard gates, weights, an anchor for every score, the linked questions and the cut-offs in one Word file. Metaview's template writes out what each score from 1 to 4 means for five sample competencies, beside an evidence column; its table has no weights or cut-offs. Manatal's sales template pairs each competency with an interview question and a 1 to 5 rating, with no anchors written in the table. We read both on 17 Nov 2026.
Should every role have its own interview scorecard?
Yes. The gates, weights and cut-offs come from each client's brief, so they change with the role. The six scorecards Recagn drafted in the interview scorecard guide ask for between 3.6 and 4.0 to qualify.